CHAPTER 8: Teaching with Contrived
Experiences
The model of the atom, the globe, the
planetarium, the simulated election process and the preserved specimen fall
under contrived experiences, the second band of experiences in Dale’s Cone of
Experience.
Contrived Experiences are “edited” copies of
reality and are used as substitute for real things when it is not practical or
not possible to bring or do the real thing in the classroom. These contrived
experiences are designed to simulate to real-life situations.
The atom, the planetarium are classified as
models. A model is a “reproduction
of a real thing in a small scale, or large scale, or exact size-but made of
synthetic materials. It is a substitute for a real thing which may or may not
be operational.” (Brown, et al, 1969)
The planetarium may also be considered a mock
up. A mock up is “an arrangement of
a real device or associated devices, displayed in such a way that
representation of reality is created. The mock up may be simplified in order to
emphasize certain features. It may be an economical reproduction of a
complicated or costly device, to be observed for learning purposes. Usually, it
is a prepared substitute for a real thing; sometimes it is a giant enlargement.
(Brown, 1969). The planetarium is an example of a mock up, in the sense that the
order or the arrangement of the planets is shown and the real processes of the
planets’ rotation on their axis and the revolution of the planets around the
sun are displayed. A mock up is a special model where the parts of
a model are singled out, heightened and magnified in order to focus on that
part or process under study. The planetarium involves a model of each of the
planet and the sun but it focuses on the processes of the planets’ rotation and
revolution and so is also considered a mock
up.
The preserved specimens fall under specimens and objects. A specimen is any individual or item considered
typical of a group, class or whole. Objects may also include artifacts displayed
in a museum or objects displayed in exhibits or preserved insect specimens in
science.
The school election process described above is a form of simulation. Simulation is a “representation of a
manageable real event in which the learner is an active participant engaged in
learning a behavior or in applying previously acquired skills or knowledge.”
(Orlich, et al, 1994). In addition to the election of class and school officers
given above, other examples of these are fire and earthquake drills which
schools usually conduct. Organizers of earthquake and fire drills create a
situation highly similar to the real situation when a building is on fire or
when an earthquake happens.
Another instructional material included in contrived experiences is game. Is there a difference
between a game and a simulation? Games are played to win while simulations need
not have a winner. Simulations seem to be more easily applied to the study of
issues rather than to processes.
REFLECTION
Contrived Experiences are edited copies of
reality that is very much important in teaching it is because it is the
substitute of the real object for example globe, maps etc. Teacher used models,
mock-ups, objects, games and specimen to overcome limitations of space and
time. It also one way of helping the learners to learn easily because of the
help of models. A teacher cannot put the earth or the solar system inside the
classroom so with the help of planetarium, the students experiencing the beauty
of the solar system, they distinguished easily the planets and the other
celestial bodies.


